I have always been a fan of Estee Lauder perfumes but the cosmetics have never disappointed either. The pencil was given to me as a Christmas gift and when I ran out, I got the refills. I am immensely pleased with the purchase and would definitely recommend the product.
I love the automatic lip pencil but do not like the four shades you now have. Please bring back the Nude shade refill. Otherwise, my automatic pencil will now be a waste. That is why only three stars. If you had the Nude shade, I would rate it five stars.
I love the chocolate in my automatic lip pencil. I have used it for years and really want it back. Everyone complimented me on this. I have tried two of the colors you have available now and they are not satisfactory. Bring back chocolate PLEASE!
I have used the Chocolate lip liner for over ten years, after trying tons of other shades and brands. Went to store today to buy refill, and almost fainted when they said it was discontinued. Then spent another 2 hours at the mall trying to find something comparable, and could not. I agree with everyone else - PLEASE bring back the Chocolate Automatic Pencil!!!!!!!!!!!!
I too am extremely disappointed that Estee Lauder discontinued chocolate. They recommended Terra in replace of chocolate, but the Terra is too oranage and not a good replacement. I have used Estee for 20+ years and chocolate has been a staple for many of those years.
I am asking you to please bring back Chocolate lip liner! I love this lip liner!!! I've tried the other shades but chocolate is the best for me. I would appreciate it so much if you would consider bringing back the color CHOCOLATE. Thank you!!! It would be appreciated if you would respond to my comment!
Love this lip liner... have bought Estee Lauder brand for years because it is GREAT. Wish I had a few more selections on the color. Estee Lauder makes it so easy from the start.. ordering, packaging and shipping has been so super!!! Thanks again for making it so easy...
BIG DISAPPOINTMENT: Chocolate lip liner has been discontinued. I just discovered this today March 13, 2014 that Estee Lauter has discontinued the chocolate lip liner, duo and refill. I have used this for many many years and it is my favorite, (the only one I use). It is terribly disappointing when something you have used for again many years gets discontinued. The store where I tried to purchase said they have had lots of disappointed customers. I hope enough people write in so they may bring it back.